My Books

Politics, Culture, and Cultural Politics

« The Council of UC Faculty Associations | Main | Haves vs. Have-Nots at Public Universities - Room for Debate Blog - NYTimes.com »

November 25, 2009

Comments

Michael~

You write, "I think case studies are an important and under-used tool in philosophy, as opposed to thought experiments ... with case studies we’re not after essential distinctions at the borders of categories. Instead, we’re trying to explore concrete situations and the “problems” they express."

I wish many of your fellow academics would follow your lead here. Thinking about zombies and other universes generate hypothetical distinctions - synthetic propositions without actual referents - and does little for practical (not simply utilitarian) thinking-in-the-world as such. Philosophy might be better off helping to clarify specialist thinking on so many concrete problems.

Regardless, I sincerely enjoy your work, and look forward to following your projects as they continue to evolve.

m-

The comments to this entry are closed.